Cincinnati’s agreement on a two-year contract with Jonathan India underscores their dedication to ensuring financial stability.
It remains uncertain whether Jonathan India will primarily play second base for the Cincinnati Reds during the 2024 season, as there are possibilities he may also see time at first base or left field. Additionally, there’s a chance he could serve as a designated hitter, contingent upon his recovery from hamstring and foot injuries that have plagued him over the past two seasons.
However, what is clear, both to Major League Baseball‘s arbitration process and observers, is India’s outstanding performance during the 2021 season, where he earned the National League Rookie of the Year award. Despite concerns about his recent injury setbacks, it’s undeniable that in his debut season, when he was fully fit, India excelled offensively, resulting in an impressive ~4 WAR (Wins Above Replacement) and accolades that arbitration values significantly.
On Friday, India and the Reds reached a resolution in their salary dispute by agreeing to a two-year contract worth approximately $8.8 million. This deal includes the potential for an additional $2.05 million in bonuses for the 2023 season, contingent upon his playing time and productivity. Consequently, India could potentially earn a comparable amount in 2024 to what he’s slated to receive in the already contracted 2025 season.
On one hand, Jonathan India’s agreement with the Reds might seem like a compromise on his part. Initially seeking $4 million for the 2024 season, he settled for less after the team countered with $3.2 million, opting not to proceed to an arbitration hearing. Although the $2.05 million bonus potential is appealing, his potential for stellar performance may essentially result in a net-neutral raise for the 2025 season, something that the arbitration process typically aims to prevent, particularly for former NL Rookie of the Year winners.
Nevertheless, the guaranteed money provides a level of financial security for India. It’s plausible that he’s acknowledged the presence of younger, less expensive options on the team’s roster and in the farm system, which could render him expendable before securing a guarantee for the 2025 season.
For the Reds, this deal contributes to their strategy of establishing cost certainty. With India’s salaries locked in for both 2024 and 2025, aside from relatively minor bonuses, he becomes a fixed component of the payroll and a more tangible trade asset for future discussions.
However, there’s also the possibility that India thrives in a corner outfield position, improves against left-handed pitchers, or maintains his health, thus potentially solidifying his role at second base defensively. Despite his limited experience at second base during college and in the minor leagues, he may demonstrate significant improvement in this aspect.
Overall, the decision to sign Jonathan India to a two-year deal instead of a one-year agreement doesn’t necessarily indicate a long-term commitment from the Reds. Rather, it sets a clear price for his services, potentially enhancing his trade value in the future.
