Former Michigan quarterback J.J. McCarthy is elevating the esteemed trio of the 2024 NFL Draft quarterback class to a quartet. Following his pivotal role in leading the Wolverines to a national championship, an impressive display at the NFL Combine, and a successful pro day, NFL franchises holding high draft picks face a compelling decision.
Among Caleb Williams, Drake Maye, Jayden Daniels, and McCarthy, who will rise to the forefront? It’s a favorable conundrum for teams with top three selections. Yet, has McCarthy’s emergence as a top 5 pick been overly hyped, or was he initially undervalued? His former coach, Jim Harbaugh, isn’t surprised by the buzz. In fact, he further bolstered McCarthy’s reputation, praising him as the quarterback who “best embodies the position” among the group.
As McCarthy’s former coach, the Los Angeles Chargers head coach possesses intimate knowledge of his capabilities and believes that McCarthy is enhancing his draft stock with standout performances, particularly at the Michigan Pro Day. Harbaugh remarked, “You could just see it,” citing the praise he received from various coaches and general managers who were impressed by McCarthy’s demeanor on and off the field.
With rumors swirling that teams like the Minnesota Vikings, Denver Broncos, and New England Patriots are eyeing McCarthy, speculation mounts about potential trades or selections. However, the prospect of the Washington Commanders selecting McCarthy at No. 2 injects further intrigue.
This scenario would present a challenging decision for teams like the Patriots, torn between Daniels and Maye, and potentially leaving one of the original top three quarterbacks available later in the draft than anticipated.
NFL Network’s Tom Pelissero raised eyebrows by suggesting that Commanders’ general manager Adam Peters might shake up mock drafts by selecting McCarthy. As Pelissero noted, there’s significant anticipation surrounding the Commanders’ decision, with insiders indicating McCarthy as a prime contender for the No. 2 pick.
The ensuing drama promises excitement for fans, particularly those invested in the Commanders’ future. With the quarterback debate initially centered on Maye and Daniels, McCarthy has emerged as a compelling option, endorsed by Harbaugh and reportedly earning the respect of NFL general managers.
After a standout season at Michigan, where he amassed nearly 3,000 passing yards and 22 touchdowns, McCarthy embodies a rare blend of talent, leadership, and resilience. The question remains: is he worthy of a top-two selection? His remarkable performances and widespread acclaim suggest that he just might be.
