Apologies for borrowing the typical angle that frames any hockey news in terms of its impact on the Toronto Maple Leafs, but speculation about Mitch Marner is on the rise. It could be a result of a slow news week where the media needs content (sticking to popular topics), and nothing captivates like the drama surrounding Toronto. Due to various connections, wishful thinking, or simply casual discussions, the idea of Pittsburgh getting involved in a potential Marner trade has sporadically surfaced online.
Considering the Penguins’ history of making bold moves and successful off-season trades for high-profile, high-cost Toronto wingers, plus the Kyle Dubas connection, it’s natural to speculate about potential links. However, this is ultimately a lost cause and a waste of time, particularly during the slow early June period when there is little else to discuss.
Pittsburgh wasn’t mentioned among the six potential destinations for Marner, who has a full no-movement clause, giving him complete control over any trade. NHL players can be unpredictable in these situations—some, like Patric Hornqvist, waive their clauses to leave, while others, like Phil Kessel, resist moves. It’s unclear how Marner feels about staying in a potentially awkward situation in Toronto with no long-term future, but this uncertainty adds an element of intrigue for the summer.
Beyond contractual hurdles, Pittsburgh is an unlikely destination for Marner due to the Brendan Shanahan factor. Given the strained relationship between Shanahan and Dubas, it’s improbable that Shanahan would trade a star player to Dubas. Additionally, Marner’s $11 million cap hit, with only one season remaining, and his history of negotiating for top dollar, pose significant financial challenges. The Penguins, who showed little interest in negotiating with Jake Guentzel for a market-rate deal, are unlikely to commit to an even larger and longer contract for Marner, especially in the late stages of the 87/71 era.
In summary, the chances of the Penguins acquiring Mitch Marner are almost non-existent for numerous reasons, including the player’s preferences, the current team’s stance, and the Penguins’ strategic direction. While it’s a topic of discussion during the slow season, the reality is that this scenario is highly improbable.
