In a pivotal moment late in the fourth quarter with scores tied, James Sicily drew a contentious downfield free kick after contact from Tom Green, who bumped into him just after he kicked inside 50. Sicily immediately appealed to the umpire, who awarded the free kick amid protests from Green and surprise among the Launceston crowd.
Adding to the drama, Luke Breust was chosen over closer Mabior Chol to take the shot on goal, a decision affirmed by league officials despite scrutiny.
After the match, Giants coach Adam Kingsley refrained from definitive comments due to his lack of clear vision on the incident: “I didn’t see the free kick, so I can’t really comment on whether it was a free kick or not – I mean he’s (Tom Green) desperate to try and stop a score, so things happen when you’re desperate to do that.”
Meanwhile, Hawks coach Sam Mitchell acknowledged the complexities of such decisions under current rules: “I was a bit worried that (Sicily) had missed the (kick); any score would’ve been great at that moment, so I’ll let the umpires (be), they’ve got a tough job – particularly at the moment.”
Reflecting on Sicily’s reaction, Hawks legend Dermott Brereton noted his tactical play: “Watch James throw the arms up in the air and deliberately allow himself to land heavy on the ground. He’s played that so cleverly.”
Breust capitalized on the opportunity with a match-winning snap from the boundary, securing Hawthorn’s victory amidst debate over the legitimacy of the crucial free kick call.
The Hawks are set to face Richmond next Saturday evening, aiming to extend their winning streak, while the Giants seek a turnaround in form against Port Adelaide at home next Sunday.
