The Atlanta Braves have clear trade deadline objectives: bolster their outfield bats and secure a dependable fifth starter. With Spencer Schwellenbach vying for the fifth spot, the Braves’ plans were disrupted by a Reynaldo Lopez injury. Max Fried remains on the IL, and Chris Sale’s late-season reliability has been a concern for years.
In essence, Atlanta needs to build depth on the mound. The team has several enticing young pitchers they could offer in trade discussions, including top prospects AJ Smith-Shawver and Hurston Waldrep, as well as more marginal options like Darius Vines or Allan Winans.
Initially, it was anticipated that Atlanta would pursue a solid mid-to-back-end rotation pitcher and leave it at that. Despite Spencer Strider’s absence, the Braves boast three All-Stars in their starting rotation this season: Sale, Fried, and Lopez. The team is not lacking in star power on the mound.
However, recent reports from Jon Heyman of the New York Post link the Braves to Garrett Crochet, the Chicago White Sox All-Star and potential Cy Young candidate, who is the most sought-after starting pitcher on the market.
A move for Crochet would be unexpected. His high price and public contract demands might deter a less aggressive front office. Crochet’s desire for a contract extension and reluctance to move to the bullpen further complicate matters. Yet, with the Braves struggling in the Wild Card race, Alex Anthopoulos might be inclined to take a bold step.
Acquiring Crochet would not only address immediate needs but could also provide insights into Max Fried’s future with the team.
Braves’ Trade for Garrett Crochet Could Determine Max Fried’s Free Agent Future
Max Fried is set to become a free agent at the end of the season and has openly expressed frustration over stalled contract negotiations, making it seem increasingly likely that he will depart. The Braves typically secure their stars with early extensions to avoid the complexities and costs of free agency. Given the interest Fried is expected to attract, with numerous lucrative offers likely coming his way, the Braves may find themselves unable to compete.
Braves are among teams considering White Sox ace Garrett Crochet. Makes sense for them if they can muster decent return. They have multiple injury losses/concerns at the top of their rotation and Crochet salary ($800K) is very reasonable.
— Jon Heyman (@JonHeyman) July 29, 2024
In this context, acquiring Garrett Crochet makes sense. At just 25 and under team control through 2026, Crochet presents a viable option for the Braves. Even if the team doesn’t extend Crochet immediately, he won’t be eligible to play in the postseason, but that’s manageable given Atlanta’s current rotation of All-Stars and Charlie Morton. Crochet could serve as valuable insurance for the 2024 season and a potential replacement for Fried in 2025.
Should the Braves choose to sign Crochet to a new contract, it would further indicate Fried’s likely departure. Despite some concerns about Crochet’s long-term durability due to a significant increase in innings pitched this season, his impressive potential makes him a strong candidate for the future. Crochet could provide strikeouts and value to the Braves for years to come.
Fried’s situation has been complex and puzzling, as he is clearly a player the Braves would want to retain. However, if a new contract seems unlikely, Crochet stands out as the best feasible alternative for the Braves. Such a trade could shake up the competition, causing alarm for rivals like the Phillies and Mets.
