Carlos Estévez #53 of the Philadelphia Phillies
The Philadelphia Phillies made a strategic midseason move this past summer, acquiring star reliever Carlos Estévez from the Los Angeles Angels to shore up their bullpen. Estévez was exactly what the Phillies needed, arriving with an impressive 2.38 ERA over his first 34 appearances of the season. His impact was immediate, stabilizing the back end of the bullpen and providing much-needed late-inning dominance.
In his 20 appearances with Philadelphia, Estévez continued to excel, posting a 2.57 ERA and recording six saves. He proved to be a key component of the Phillies’ success down the stretch, helping the team stay competitive during the regular season. However, the team now faces a tough offseason decision regarding his future. Estévez is set to hit free agency, and projections suggest he could command a hefty contract—approximately $69 million over five years.
The Phillies are certainly in a position to afford such a deal, but the question is whether they will prioritize bringing him back. Estévez’s value is evident, yet it remains uncertain if the Phillies are willing to make that kind of long-term commitment to the reliever.
According to ESPN’s David Schoenfield, Estévez may not be in Philadelphia’s plans for 2025. “It could be a similar offseason, when the only significant moves are re-signing the two relievers. (Jeff Hoffman) is the better pitcher, although Estevez has the closer pedigree. If you could pick just one, I’d go with Hoffman and let another team overpay for Estevez,” Schoenfield explained.
Schoenfield’s assessment highlights the dilemma facing the Phillies. While Estévez delivered in a crucial time for the team, they may opt to keep the more versatile Hoffman and allow another team to meet Estévez’s likely high market value. Regardless of what happens, Estévez’s brief tenure in Philadelphia showed his reliability and talent, making him a coveted option for teams needing bullpen help.
