The Philadelphia Phillies are entering the offseason with mixed feelings. After a season that showcased their potential as a World Series contender, the team’s journey came to a sudden halt in the National League Division Series, where they fell to the New York Mets. While the roster has its strengths, the early exit has highlighted some areas that desperately need improvement, particularly in the starting rotation.
A Missed Opportunity Exposed
Despite a talented lineup, one glaring weakness for the Phillies was the fifth spot in their rotation. Taijuan Walker struggled throughout the season, posting an alarming ERA over 7.00, which was a stark contrast to his solid 15-win campaign in 2023. With Walker’s performance often resembling an automatic loss, it’s clear that finding a reliable replacement is a top priority for the Phillies this offseason.
Targeting Garrett Crochet
In light of this need, a recent proposal by Kerry Miller of Bleacher Report has emerged, suggesting a potential trade that could bring Garrett Crochet from the Chicago White Sox to Philadelphia. The hypothetical deal would see the Phillies sending shortstop Aidan Miller, catcher Eduardo Tait, and right-handed pitcher Seth Johnson to Chicago in exchange for the left-handed starter.
Miller notes that this trade could be appealing for the Phillies as they already have one of the highest payrolls in the league. With Crochet projected to earn just $2.9 million in arbitration, he fits the budget while providing a significant upgrade in the rotation. The inclusion of Aidan Miller, a first-round pick from 2023, might seem steep, but if it means acquiring a pitcher of Crochet’s caliber without touching other top prospects like Andrew Painter or center fielder Justin Crawford, it could be worth the investment.
A New Look for the Rotation
Acquiring Crochet would bolster a talented pitching staff that includes Zack Wheeler, Aaron Nola, Ranger Suarez, and Christopher Sanchez. With Crochet’s ability to perform at a high level, he could help stabilize the rotation and provide much-needed depth. The southpaw’s affordability only adds to the allure; while he’ll be seeking a new contract soon, the Phillies could potentially navigate through the 2025 season before locking him up for the long term.
Making a Splash After Disappointment
The Phillies entered the 2024 season with lofty World Series aspirations, and an early playoff exit has left fans and management alike hungry for change. Making a significant move like trading for a promising pitcher such as Crochet would not only address an immediate need but also signal to fans that the organization is committed to contending at the highest level.
As the offseason unfolds, the spotlight will be on the Phillies to address their rotation and ensure they don’t miss out on another opportunity to compete for a championship. Adding Crochet to the mix could very well be the key to turning their potential into postseason success. If the Phillies can execute this trade, it could mark the beginning of an exciting new chapter for the team as they look to reclaim their place among the league’s elite.
