Brandon Marsh #16 of the Philadelphia Phillies
Could Brandon Marsh Be on the Trade Block for the Phillies?
The Philadelphia Phillies kicked off their 2025 season with a victory over the Washington Nationals, but Opening Day wasn’t without its rough spots. While the team delivered some electrifying moments, there were also struggles at the plate—none more glaring than those of Brandon Marsh. The outfielder endured a frustrating day, striking out in all four of his at-bats, often letting hittable pitches pass him by.
Marsh’s struggles at the plate have been a concern throughout his MLB career. Despite showing some improvement, he still displays an overly patient approach that results in too many called strikes. Given Philadelphia’s championship aspirations, the front office may need to consider whether Marsh remains the best fit in their lineup.
A Trade Proposal: Marsh to Kansas City?
One potential solution could be dealing Marsh to the Kansas City Royals. The Royals, still in the midst of their rebuild, could benefit from Marsh’s defensive prowess and potential upside as an everyday center fielder. In return, the Phillies could look to acquire veteran outfielder Hunter Renfroe and promising pitching prospect Steven Zobac.
Renfroe, known for his power bat and solid outfield defense, would provide Philadelphia with another veteran presence in the lineup. Meanwhile, Zobac, a young pitcher with upside, could bolster the Phillies’ pitching depth.
What Would the Phillies’ Outfield Look Like Without Marsh?
If the Phillies decide to move on from Marsh, Johan Rojas would likely take over full-time duties in center field. Rojas brings elite defensive ability and strong athleticism, making him a viable replacement. Additionally, a Marsh trade could create an opportunity for the Phillies to pursue a high-caliber center fielder via trade, such as the White Sox’s Luis Robert Jr.
Marsh’s remaining years of team control make him an appealing trade chip, especially for teams seeking long-term stability in the outfield. While he has had memorable moments in Philadelphia, the Phillies’ win-now mentality could push them to explore upgrades at the position.
Would the Phillies Pull the Trigger?
While this is just a hypothetical trade pitch, it’s not outside the realm of possibility. Marsh still has value, but his limitations at the plate may lead the Phillies to pursue a more consistent bat for their postseason push. If Philadelphia determines they need a more reliable offensive presence in center field, moving on from Marsh could become a real option as the season unfolds.
