Cincinnati Reds shortstop Elly De La Cruz is embraced by his teammates after coming off the field in the first inning of a Cactus League game between the Cincinnati Reds and Los Angeles Dodgers, Monday, Feb. 24, 2025, at Goodyear Ballpark in Goodyear, Ariz.
Cincinnati Reds at the Crossroads: Sweep or Surrender in the Playoff Chase
The Cincinnati Reds have reached the razor’s edge of their 2025 season. After months of fighting, clawing, and hanging around the fringes of the Wild Card race, the moment of truth has finally arrived. Friday night at Great American Ball Park, the New York Mets come to town—and for the Reds, the math is brutally simple: sweep or watch the playoff dream slip away.
A Standings Reality Check
Wednesday’s loss dealt a punishing blow. Coupled with a San Francisco Giants win, the Reds slid to fifth in the Wild Card standings. Only three teams punch a ticket to October baseball. Now sitting five games behind the Mets and a full game behind the Giants, Cincinnati faces a mountain that can only be climbed with urgency and perfection.
The calendar is the enemy. With just 22 games remaining, every inning feels heavier. If both the Mets and Giants simply play .500 baseball down the stretch, the Reds would need to rip off a blistering 16–6 finish just to tie New York.
That’s not impossible—but it’s perilously close to it.
The Tiebreaker Factor
There is one sliver of hope. Major League Baseball’s new tiebreaker rules favor head-to-head results. Cincinnati already took two of three from the Mets earlier this summer in New York. If the Reds can win this weekend series, they’d own the tiebreaker. But here’s the catch: winning two out of three won’t be enough.
If Cincinnati emerges from Sunday at 72–71, the uphill battle continues. With the likely target for the final Wild Card spot sitting at 86 wins, they would still need to finish an eye-watering 14–5 the rest of the way. A sweep, however, keeps the dream alive and resets the conversation.
Why Every Game Doesn’t Count the Same
Baseball wisdom often insists that “every game counts the same.” Mathematically? Sure. But context matters. Beating the Colorado Rockies in April doesn’t hit the standings with the same impact as beating the team you’re chasing in September. When you take down a direct competitor, you don’t just win—you make them lose.
That’s what makes this Mets series so monumental. These aren’t just three games. They’re three elimination battles wrapped in one weekend.
The Odds, the Urgency, and the Impossible Dream
Even in the best-case scenario—a sweep—the road ahead remains brutal. Cincinnati still needs both New York and San Francisco to stumble, something neither team has shown much interest in doing. But without a sweep? The path becomes fantasy.
There is no “we’ll get hot later.” The season is too short, the gap too wide, and the competition too steady. For the Reds, the time to catch fire isn’t later. It’s right now.
No Margin for Error
This is what September baseball is all about. Every pitch becomes a referendum on the season. Every mistake could be the one that ends it. Cincinnati can still write a miracle story, but the pen is running out of ink.
The Mets are in town. The standings are merciless. The Reds have one chance left to flip the script.
Sweep—or surrender.
About the Author
