Zack Meisel from The Athletic recently hinted at talks within the Guardians organization regarding potential player contract extensions. While Meisel’s insights are always valuable, let’s explore some players who might be involved in these discussions.
Top Contenders for Extensions:
1. Steven Kwan (26 years old, under contract until 2027): The Guardians engaged in extension talks with Kwan last season, and leaked information suggests possible terms. It’s plausible that Kwan’s recent performance slump could make him more open to a deal, perhaps around 7 years and $56 million. However, I doubt he’d accept an extension exceeding $10 million per year without proving his worth.
2. Tanner Bibee (25 years old, under contract until 2028): Bibee’s exceptional rookie season has likely caught the Guardians’ attention. Given the unpredictable nature of pitching, a deal ensuring security for Bibee while buying out a couple of free agency years could be mutually beneficial. A contract like 7 years for $77 million might be plausible, albeit with incentives and opt-outs.
Promising Young Players to Consider:
1. Bo Naylor (24 years old, under contract until 2029): Extending contracts for young talents like Naylor could help the Guardians control costs and secure future talent. A potential deal like 8 years for $72 million, with incentives for All-Star appearances, might interest Naylor and his agent.
2. Chase DeLauter (22 years old, yet to debut for the Guardians): While the team typically doesn’t extend prospects before their debut, DeLauter’s potential warrants consideration. Offering a deal similar to Jackson Chourio’s 8/$82 million could be a strategic move if DeLauter lives up to expectations.
#2 – Josh Naylor’s weekend rampage against the Angels (3 go ahead home runs in the 8th inning 3 days in a row) pic.twitter.com/bsUgzyylux
— Bryce is ready for baseball (@mlbeuphoria) December 28, 2023
Under-the-Radar Candidates:
1. Tyler Freeman (24 years old, under contract until 2028): Despite recent setbacks, Freeman has showcased his utility potential. Offering him a contract extension, perhaps similar to Myles Straw’s deal, could provide value for the team.
2. Scott Barlow (31 years old, under contract until 2024): Barlow’s role in the team and his pitching style make him a potential extension candidate. A two-year deal worth $12-14 million might interest both parties.
.@CleGuardians players consider Stephen Vogt a gamer, a great leader, and a really smart guy.
And they're ready to work hard for him.#ForTheLand | #GuardsSpring | #WayToOpeningDay pic.twitter.com/gcu6gzkgk8
— Bally Sports Cleveland (@BallySportsCLE) March 12, 2024
Personal Favorites and Long Shots:
1. Josh Naylor (26 years old, under contract until 2025): Naylor’s leadership qualities and batting skills make him an intriguing candidate for extension. While his recent injury raises concerns, a deal like 6 years for $72 million, including incentives, could benefit both parties.
2. Triston McKenzie (26 years old, under contract until 2026): Despite injury risks, McKenzie’s talent and character make him a compelling choice for extension. A deal offering $32 million guaranteed for four years, with incentives and opt-outs, could be worth exploring.
3. Shane Bieber (28 years old, under contract until 2024): Extending Bieber might seem unlikely, but his consistency and potential warrant consideration. While a $100 million deal over seven years might be ambitious, Bieber’s track record suggests it’s not impossible.
Predictions:
Given the Guardians’ history of spring extensions, it’s plausible that a deal similar to Kluber or Carrasco’s could be struck with Tanner Bibee before the Home Opener. Time will tell!
