
ANN ARBOR, MI - NOVEMBER 19: Michigan Wolverines trainers and Michigan Wolverines head coach Jim Harbaugh look at Michigan Wolverines running back Blake Corum (2) after he went down with an injury near the sidelines during the Michigan Wolverines versus the Illinois Fighting Illini on Saturday November 19, 2022 at Michigan Stadium in Ann Arbor, MI. (Photo by Steven King/Icon Sportswire via Getty Images)
The Michigan Wolverines have long prided themselves on their elite football program, consistently attracting top-tier recruits and competing for national championships. This recruiting success, however, has faced some recent turbulence, particularly when it comes to the program’s pursuit of its top quarterback target for the 2025 class. The Wolverines were eyeing the nation’s top quarterback prospect, Bryce Underwood, as a cornerstone of their future offense. Unfortunately for Michigan, they recently received a disappointing update regarding Underwood’s recruitment that has left the team’s coaching staff and fanbase reeling.

A Promising Start to the Recruitment
Bryce Underwood, a 6-foot-4, 210-pound quarterback out of Belleville, Michigan, is regarded as one of the top high school quarterbacks in the country. Underwood’s arm strength, mobility, and football IQ had drawn attention from the best programs across the nation, with many predicting that he would be the next big star in college football. As a local product, Michigan was considered the favorite to land Underwood, and there was a great deal of optimism surrounding his recruitment.
Michigan’s head coach Jim Harbaugh, known for his quarterback development expertise, made it clear that he viewed Underwood as the future of the Wolverines’ offense. Underwood was seen as the perfect fit for Michigan’s pro-style system, capable of leading the team with his powerful arm and high football IQ. This alignment between Underwood’s skill set and Michigan’s needs seemed like a match made in heaven.
The Setback: Michigan’s Disappointing Update
After months of anticipation, the Wolverines received a shock when it was reported that Bryce Underwood was no longer considering Michigan as his top option. While initially there had been optimism surrounding his potential commitment, Underwood ultimately chose to focus his recruitment elsewhere. This update was a huge blow to Michigan’s recruiting efforts, especially considering the high expectations placed on Underwood as the future quarterback.
Underwood’s decision to pull back from Michigan came after several high-profile visits and discussions. Although Michigan had been positioning itself as a contender, it became increasingly clear that Underwood had other options that were becoming more appealing. The Wolverines’ inability to secure a commitment from Underwood, particularly with their strong pitch and proximity to home, has led many to question what went wrong in the recruitment process.
A Closer Look at the Competition
As Underwood’s recruitment progressed, other programs began to ramp up their efforts to secure his commitment. One of Michigan’s biggest competitors was Ohio State, a perennial powerhouse in college football. Ohio State’s offensive system and recent success at developing quarterbacks were major selling points in their recruitment of Underwood. The Buckeyes, led by head coach Ryan Day, have a history of producing high-caliber quarterbacks who go on to thrive in the NFL. This proved to be a significant factor for Underwood, who began to view Ohio State as a viable option.
In addition to Ohio State, other schools, including Alabama, Georgia, and LSU, also made strong pushes for Underwood’s services. Each of these programs offered unique opportunities for Underwood, whether it was the chance to play in a high-powered offense or the appeal of competing for national championships year in and year out. Michigan, despite its strong tradition and recent success under Jim Harbaugh, found itself in a more difficult position as the competition grew more intense.
The NIL Factor
In recent years, the Name, Image, and Likeness (NIL) landscape has become a significant factor in college recruiting. For top-tier recruits like Underwood, NIL opportunities can often play a large role in their decision-making process. Michigan, while a traditional powerhouse, has been slow to fully embrace the NIL era in comparison to some of its competitors. Programs like Alabama, Georgia, and Ohio State have been able to offer lucrative NIL deals that entice high-profile recruits, including quarterbacks like Underwood.
Reports surfaced that Michigan was working to match or exceed the NIL offers of its competitors. However, it appeared that Underwood’s final decision was influenced not just by football opportunities but also by the NIL packages on the table. In this new era of recruiting, where money is a significant factor, Michigan’s relatively slower adoption of NIL offerings may have hurt their chances with Underwood.
Impact on Michigan’s Future Quarterback Situation
The news of Underwood’s decision to move forward with other schools has major implications for Michigan’s quarterback situation moving forward. The Wolverines were counting on Underwood to be their next star quarterback, someone who could lead the offense for the next several years. With Underwood now out of the picture, Michigan finds itself searching for a new top-tier quarterback prospect to anchor its future.
While Michigan still has other talented quarterbacks on the roster, including 2024 recruits, none have the same level of hype or potential as Underwood. The Wolverines’ depth chart at quarterback could be more unsettled in the coming years as the coaching staff searches for a new franchise quarterback. The loss of Underwood means that Michigan will need to explore other avenues in its recruiting strategy and possibly focus on developing younger quarterbacks already in the program or hitting the transfer portal for an experienced player.
The Coaching Staff’s Response
Following the disappointing news about Underwood, Michigan’s coaching staff has remained optimistic but realistic. Jim Harbaugh, who has long been known for his ability to develop quarterbacks, will likely shift his attention to other quarterback prospects for the 2025 class. The Wolverines will continue to prioritize finding a quarterback who can run their offense efficiently and lead the team to a championship. However, Harbaugh and his staff may now need to look beyond just one recruit to fill the void left by Underwood.
In the meantime, the current quarterbacks on Michigan’s roster, including J.J. McCarthy, will need to continue their development and work hard to keep the Wolverines competitive in the Big Ten and beyond. McCarthy, who has had some success in his time as Michigan’s starter, could be the key to Michigan’s immediate future while the coaching staff works to solidify the quarterback position for the long term.
Moving Forward
Despite the setback, Michigan’s football program remains in a strong position overall. The Wolverines continue to recruit at a high level and have a solid foundation in place for the future. While the loss of Bryce Underwood stings, the Wolverines are far from being out of the running for top-tier recruits. In the ever-changing world of college football recruiting, things can shift quickly, and Michigan will likely be back in the mix for other top quarterbacks in future recruiting cycles.
Ultimately, Michigan’s goal will be to maintain its status as a national contender while adapting to the evolving landscape of recruiting, NIL, and player development. The Wolverines have faced adversity before and emerged stronger, and this latest setback in their pursuit of Underwood will only serve as fuel for their continued growth and future success.
As Michigan moves forward in its search for a quarterback of the future, fans and coaches alike will be eager to see how the program adjusts and continues to compete at the highest level in college football.