During the recent Hockey Night In Canada broadcast, Elliotte Friedman shared updates regarding the Edmonton Oilers and their prospect defenseman Philip Broberg.
Despite rumors of the Oilers targeting significant acquisitions approaching the Trade Deadline, general manager Ken Holland made it clear to other teams that he has no intention of trading Broberg for a rental player. The 22-year-old defenseman has been showcasing impressive skills since his assignment to the Bakersfield Condors. Despite his current injury, he has amassed 19 points in 29 AHL games, often logging substantial ice time. While the development of defensemen typically takes time, many Oilers fans have grown impatient with Broberg, given that he has yet to establish himself as a regular NHL player five years after being drafted.
Nevertheless, I find myself supporting Holland’s decision in this matter. While AHL performance doesn’t always directly translate to success in the NHL, Broberg undoubtedly possesses talent. Even if Holland were open to such a trade, its viability would hinge on the specific rental player being considered. The recent injury to Jake Guentzel may prompt other teams to reconsider trading for him, casting doubt on potential deals. While I previously entertained the notion of acquiring Vladimir Tarasenko in another article, I wouldn’t advocate trading Broberg for him. Instead, I believe that only an offer involving a Guentzel-like forward with term or a right-handed defenseman similar to Ekholm would warrant consideration for Broberg’s trade.
There’s speculation that Broberg may rejoin the Oilers’ lineup in the event of an injury or if either Brett Kulak or Cody Ceci is moved. However, if the latter scenario unfolds, I believe it would be preferable to pair Darnell Nurse with a seasoned veteran rather than rushing Broberg back into the lineup during this critical stage of the season, especially given the team’s aspirations for a championship.
Personally, I am inclined to view Broberg’s potential return to the Oilers’ lineup as contingent on injury situations.
