General Manager Joe Schoen of the New York Giants
With just over a month left in the 2024 NFL regular season, the New York Giants’ playoff hopes have long since faded. At 2-10 and riding a seven-game losing streak heading into Week 14, it’s clear the team is already looking ahead to the offseason. For Giants fans, the silver lining is the possibility of securing a top pick in the 2025 NFL Draft. As it stands, the Giants hold the No. 3 overall pick, but depending on tiebreakers, they could still snag the coveted No. 1 spot, setting the stage for a pivotal offseason.
Given their struggles at quarterback this season, it seems nearly inevitable that the Giants will use their high draft pick to select a quarterback — and one of the most intriguing names being linked to them is Colorado’s standout, Shedeur Sanders.
The Quarterback Dilemma: Will Sanders Be the Pick?
With a glaring need under center, the Giants are expected to address their quarterback situation in the upcoming draft, no matter what. General manager Joe Schoen will likely make the call, but it seems certain that a quarterback will be the top priority. The biggest question remains: Who will that quarterback be?
In his most recent mock draft, Dane Brugler of The Athletic has the Giants selecting Shedeur Sanders, arguably the most polarizing quarterback in the 2025 class. Sanders, the star signal-caller for Colorado, has impressed many with his arm strength, poise, and ability to perform under pressure. However, some NFL teams have been hesitant to fully buy into his status as a franchise quarterback, grading him as an “adequate” starter rather than a future star. Despite the mixed opinions, Brugler believes that with the right coaching — particularly under head coach Brian Daboll — Sanders could thrive at the NFL level.
The Giants will likely be tied to Sanders for the rest of the offseason as the draft approaches, especially as the 21-year-old prepares to declare for the 2025 draft. His high-profile status and his ability to generate conversation make him the most-discussed quarterback prospect for New York.
Sanders’ 2024 Season: A Star in the Making
In 12 games this season, Sanders has put up impressive numbers, completing 74.2% of his passes for 3,926 yards, 35 touchdowns, and just 8 interceptions. His ability to move the ball downfield while keeping turnovers in check has been a standout feature of his game, making him one of the most productive quarterbacks in college football this season. Sanders’ performance has solidified his status as one of the top quarterback prospects in the country, and with the Giants’ struggles under center, it’s easy to see why they would target him at the top of the draft.
While Sanders’ play on the field speaks for itself, there are still questions about how his game will translate to the NFL. Some critics question whether he will be able to adjust to the speed and complexity of professional defenses, but there’s no denying his potential. With a coach like Daboll, who has worked with quarterbacks like Josh Allen in the past, the Giants would hope that Sanders’ raw talent and ability to learn quickly would help him develop into a star at the next level.
Who Else Is In The Mix?
In Brugler’s mock draft, only two quarterbacks went in the first round. Along with Sanders, Cam Ward from Miami was selected ahead of the Giants at No. 2 overall by the Las Vegas Raiders. Ward’s selection over Sanders in this mock speaks to the competition among top quarterbacks in the 2025 class. While Sanders seems to be the frontrunner for the Giants at No. 3, there are several other prospects who could emerge as potential targets as the draft process unfolds.
Given the level of talent at the top of the draft, the Giants may have options even if they don’t land the No. 1 overall pick. However, if they stay at No. 3, Sanders would likely be the best fit — both for his ability to step in immediately and for his long-term potential as a franchise quarterback.
Looking Ahead to the 2025 NFL Draft
As the 2024 season winds down for the New York Giants, all eyes will be on the 2025 NFL Draft and their quarterback decision. With a top-three pick in hand, they are positioned to add a game-changing player under center — something the team has desperately needed. Whether it’s Sanders or another top quarterback, the Giants’ future will hinge on their ability to make the right call at the most important position on the field.
For now, Giants fans are left to wait and hope that the team’s fortunes will change — not just for the rest of this season, but for the future of the franchise.
